Despite common’s heather’s relatively muted appearance, its sheer abundance and profusion leave you in little doubt as to which one you are looking at. Bell heather can grow in rather large concentrations but they’re just that. Concentrations. Common heather, on the other hand, grows everywhere!
This is because while all three plants are rather hardy, common heather is especially so. Admittedly it grows in a somewhat stunted form the higher up a hillside you go, but its tolerance of cold, wind, altitude and salty sea-spray means it can grow just about anywhere from sea to summit, thriving in environments that most other plants would baulk at the thought of.
It mightn’t have the gaudy purple of Bell Heather but what it lacks in gaudiness it more than makes up in range and the number of flowers on each plant. As a result, aided by human management of moorlands, common heather grows so widely and flowers so enthusiastically that it is able to change the colour of entire hillsides in summer.
Of course, finding these three heathers handily growing together so that you can make a visual on-the-spot comparison isn’t assured. So if when faced with a lone heather you’re still not sure which one it is, or if it’s Winter or Spring and there are no flowers to see, then the leaves should give it away.
Common heather’s leaves overlap one another, are short and grow in dense concentrations, whereas the heaths have ‘whorls’ of needle-like leaves that occur at more spacious intervals up the stem.
Telling the difference between the two heaths is more problematic as they are superficially similar to one another but, as the name suggests, cross-leaved heath has crosses of four leaves radiating out of its stem. Bell Heather has whorls of three leaves, not four, although they can be difficult to discern sometimes.
Cross-leaved heath also has rather obvious hairs on its leaves. These give the plant a faintly greyish appearance when viewed from afar and make the whole plant look a bit paler than bell heather.
There’s damp and there’s damp
The kinds of environments you find heaths in and the other plants they’re growing with are other useful aids to identification. Though they both thrive in the generally damp uplands of Scotland, there’s damp…..and then there’s damp.
Bell heather is no lover of boggy places and will favour the drier, better-drained surfaces. Cross-leaved heath favours the opposite and will be found flowering on the fringes of bogs and wet places alongside other bog-loving species.
At the moment (in July and August) such species are ones like bog asphodel, a striking and beautiful orange-yellow flower that is currently dotting many a highland glen.
Seen together, cross-leaved heath and bog asphodel scream ‘BOG’ loudly and mark the wet places like wee flags, whereas the lurid purple of bell heather poking through stands of common heather tends to indicate where the drier ground might be. Who knows? If you’re someone who eschews paths in favour of the open hillside, that could make the difference between dry boots and wet, squelchy boots.
“But EVERYWHERE is wet in Scotland”, I hear you say.
Well, naturally there are no cast-iron guarantees in this regard. This is Scotland after all, where water clings to slopes at angles that defy gravity and physics. But this general rule is still a good one to know, and hopefully it illustrates why being able to identify plants in the field can assist you in reading the terrain on the hill, and better understanding the lie of the land beneath your feet.
https://www.walkhighlands.co.uk/news/a-guide-to-scottish-heathers/0...